Meta asked the U.S. Supreme Court to strike down Washington state's campaign finance disclosure law and vacate a $35 million penalty, according to a petition filed on November 13 and docketed as No. 26-649. The company argues that the law's requirements are so burdensome that they amount to a ban on political advertising, and that the ban violates the First Amendment.

The penalty is the largest campaign finance fine in U.S. history. It covers 822 separate failures to disclose required information, and it has already been paid, with interest, at roughly $51 million. The case gives the Supreme Court a concrete record on a question that has divided the lower courts: how far a state can go in requiring platforms to collect and publish information about the political ads they sell.

What Washington requires

Washington's Fair Campaign Practices Act was passed by voters more than fifty years ago. It requires an ad seller to disclose the names and addresses of the people who purchased political ads, the audience the ads were aimed at, the payments, and the number of impressions. The information has to be provided to anyone who asks within two business days.

The penalties are per violation. The base fine is $10,000 per ad, and it can be tripled for intentional violations, up to $30,000 per ad. The 822 failures in Meta's case produced the $35 million judgment, plus about $10 million toward the state's legal fees.

The law was written for a world of newspapers and broadcasters. Its application to digital platforms is where the dispute lives. A newspaper can describe its circulation. A platform has to compile demographic and targeting data that it may not use for anything else, and it has to do so on a deadline.

How the fight began

The dispute goes back to 2017, when Washington's attorney general requested ad data from Google and Facebook. The office sued after what it described as incomplete compliance. The companies paid fines and said they would stop selling political ads in Washington, but they did not stop, and the state sued again in 2020.

The second case produced the 822 violations and the $35 million judgment. The Washington Supreme Court upheld the penalty in a split decision in June 2026. The justices disagreed about whether the penalty was excessive, and because no majority formed on that question, the judgment stood.

The arithmetic behind the judgment is worth spelling out. The base penalty was $10,000 per ad for the failures to disclose. The court tripled that to $30,000 for each violation it found to be intentional, and it added about $10 million in legal fees. The 822 violations produced the $35 million total, and interest brought the amount Meta paid to roughly $51 million.

Meta did not dispute that it failed to provide the information. Its argument is that the requirement itself is unconstitutional, which is why the case is about the law rather than about the company's compliance. That posture matters for the Supreme Court: the Court can strike the law without disturbing the factual finding that Meta did not comply.

Meta paid the judgment with interest. State officials have cautioned lawmakers not to spend the money while the Supreme Court petition is pending, a sign that the state takes the possibility of reversal seriously.

Meta's argument

Meta's petition, filed by Paul Clement, a former solicitor general, argues that the disclosure regime is not a disclosure regime at all. The company says the requirements are so onerous that they have caused several forums to stop running political advertisements altogether, and that the result is a ban on core political speech.

The company's brief makes a differential-treatment argument as well. Newspapers and broadcasters are not required to compile demographic targeting data, while digital platforms are. Meta says that difference reflects a misunderstanding of how digital advertising works, and that the state court ignored the distinct First Amendment problems the digital requirements create.

Meta also argues that the Washington Supreme Court's decision conflicts with a Fourth Circuit ruling that struck down a similar Maryland law. That conflict is the kind of circuit split the Supreme Court often cites when it grants review. The state court expressly diverged from the Fourth Circuit, which strengthens the case for certiorari.

The Maryland precedent

The Fourth Circuit's Maryland decision gave Meta a template. Maryland's law required platforms to publish information about political ads, and the court found that the burden and the compelled disclosure raised First Amendment problems. Washington's Supreme Court considered the decision and declined to follow it.

The disagreement between the two courts is about how to characterize the burden. The Fourth Circuit treated the disclosure requirements as a significant intrusion on editorial discretion and on the platform's speech. The Washington court treated them as ordinary transparency rules that apply to a commercial activity.

A state supreme court is not bound by a federal circuit court, so the divergence is not a direct conflict in the technical sense. It is a conflict in reasoning, and the Supreme Court often takes cases to resolve exactly that kind of disagreement. The petition leans on the split, and the state's response will have to explain why Washington's law is different from Maryland's.

Washington's defense

Washington's attorney general, Nick Brown, called the state court decision a major win for election transparency. His office said the state's disclosure laws apply regardless of the size of the advertiser or the platform, and that the public has a right to know who is paying for political messages.

The state's position is that Meta chose to sell political ads in Washington, and that the disclosure requirements are the condition of doing so. A company that finds the conditions too burdensome can stop selling the ads. Meta did not stop, and the state argues that it cannot both take the market and refuse the disclosure.

The state also has the judgment on its side. The public interest it asserts is not abstract: the law was passed by voters, and the disclosures are meant to let any member of the public see who is paying for a political message and who is being targeted. A platform that sells the ad has the data, the state argues, and the law asks it to share that data on a timetable that makes the information useful during an election. Two courts have now considered the penalty, and the state Supreme Court upheld it. The petition asks the U.S. Supreme Court to override that judgment, which requires the Court to find a federal constitutional problem with the state's law.

The legal question

The case turns on the First Amendment doctrine of compelled disclosure. The Supreme Court has generally upheld disclosure requirements for political spending, on the theory that transparency serves the public interest and imposes a limited burden. It has also struck down requirements that are so burdensome that they chill speech.

The question is where Washington's law falls. Meta says the two-day deadline and the targeting data requirement cross the line. Washington says the requirements are ordinary disclosure rules applied to a new medium. The lower courts split, and the Supreme Court will have to choose a framework.

The doctrine gives both sides material. The Court has upheld disclosure requirements for campaign spending since the 1970s, on the theory that the public interest in knowing who funds political speech outweighs the burden on the speaker. It has also recognized that disclosure can become a tool of harassment or a burden so heavy that it suppresses speech. The Washington case asks the Court to decide which side of that line a detailed digital-advertising regime falls on.

The Court does not have to take the case. It grants certiorari in a small fraction of petitions, and a denial would leave the Washington judgment in place. The Court is likely to decide whether to grant review by the end of June 2027. A decision on the merits could come by June 2028.

What it means

For platforms, the case is about the cost of selling political ads. A ruling for Meta would limit the data that states can require, and it would make it easier for platforms to stay in the political advertising market without building disclosure systems. A ruling for Washington would affirm that states can impose detailed transparency requirements, and it would encourage other states to follow.

For advertisers and voters, the stakes are different. Disclosure rules are meant to tell the public who is paying for a political message. A platform that exits the market makes that information unavailable, which is the outcome Meta says the law produces. The state says the answer is to comply, not to leave.

The timing matters for the broader debate. If the Court takes the case, its decision could land in the middle of the 2028 election cycle, when the rules for political advertising will be at their most consequential. A ruling that narrows state disclosure laws would change what voters can learn about digital ads in the states that have them. A ruling that upholds Washington's law would give other states a model.

The case also fits a broader pattern. States have been active on technology and speech regulation while the federal government has not, and the courts have become the place where the boundaries are drawn. The Washington case is one of several that will define how far states can go.

The price of the market

The petition frames the case as a choice between disclosure and silence. Washington frames it as a choice between compliance and exit. The Supreme Court will decide which framing the Constitution supports, and its answer will shape the rules for political advertising in every state that has a disclosure law.

For now, the judgment stands and the money has been paid, and the legal question remains open. The next move is the Court's, and the calendar gives it more than a year to make it. Every platform that sells political ads, and every state that regulates them, has a stake in the answer.

Primary sources

  1. Meta's petition for certiorari, No. 26-649, for the legal arguments and the requested relief.
  2. Arcamax, for the penalty details, the Washington law's requirements, and the procedural history.
  3. The Washington Supreme Court's June 2026 decision, for the judgment under review.