The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services proposed a rule on November 16 that would tighten enrollment, auditing, and reporting across Medicare, Medicaid, the Children's Health Insurance Program, and the Affordable Care Act Marketplace. The rule, published in the Federal Register on November 19, is called Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare, or CRUSH. The agency projects nearly $90 billion in taxpayer savings over ten years.
The rule is a proposal, with a 60-day comment period that runs to January 19, 2027. It is also the largest program-integrity package CMS has proposed in years, the agency said, and it touches nearly every part of the agency's fraud and abuse machinery. The $90 billion figure is a projection, not a finding, and the mechanism matters more than the headline.
How the rule fits together
CRUSH is not a single program. It is a package of changes that share a premise: the agency should verify more before it pays, and it should learn faster when something looks wrong. The February request for information asked the industry what tools it needed. The 560-plus comments that followed shaped the proposal, and the executive order creating a White House task force on fraud gave the effort political backing.
The rule is also designed to be repeatable. CMS has said it intends to issue a CRUSH-style rule every year, which means the compliance baseline will move annually rather than in a single overhaul. For providers and plans, that is a different kind of planning problem: the direction is set, and the details will change each year.
The proposal covers Medicare, Medicaid, CHIP, and the Marketplace, but it does not change benefits, eligibility, or payment rates. Its tools are enrollment, audit, reporting, and suspension. That distinction matters for the public debate, because a rule that changes who can bill is different from a rule that changes what is covered.
The RADV change
The largest single item is a change to Medicare Advantage risk adjustment data validation, known as RADV. The rule would codify the agency's approach to extrapolating audit findings across a plan's payments, without applying a fee-for-service adjuster, starting with payment year 2018. CMS estimates the change would recover about $9 billion a year.
The RADV methodology has been contested for years. Medicare Advantage plans are paid based on the diagnoses they document, and audits check whether those diagnoses are supported by the medical record. Extrapolation takes the error rate from a sample and applies it to the broader population. Plans have argued that the method overstates errors; CMS has argued that sampling is the only practical way to audit a large program.
Codifying the method would settle the question in the agency's favor and make the financial exposure more predictable. It would also increase the stakes of every RADV audit, because the extrapolated amount can be much larger than the sample.
The payment dispute behind RADV
Medicare Advantage plans are paid a risk-adjusted capitation rate. The plan documents the diagnoses of its members, and the payment rises when the documented conditions are more severe. The audit checks whether the diagnoses are supported by the medical record.
The dispute is about what happens when the audit finds errors. The agency's method extrapolates the error rate from the sample to the plan's full payment, which can produce a recovery much larger than the sample. The plan industry has argued that the method compounds small documentation errors into large financial penalties. The agency has argued that without extrapolation, a plan could keep the gains from errors it did not sample.
The rule would codify the agency's method and apply it to payment year 2018 and later. That is a long lookback, and it means plans should expect the audits to reach older payment years. The financial exposure depends on the error rates and the size of the plan.
Enrollment and reporting
The rule would broaden the agency's authority to deny or revoke enrollment. It would allow CMS to act when an owner cannot be verified or when the agency determines there is an undue risk of fraud. It would require providers and suppliers to report certain enrollment changes within 30 days.
For Medicare Advantage and Part D, the rule would require plans to report suspected or substantiated fraud, waste, and abuse, and to report payment suspensions. It would expand the definition of a credible allegation of fraud for Medicare Advantage. It would also require certain providers that bill Medicare Advantage to enroll in Original Medicare, which gives the agency a direct relationship with the provider and a way to apply its enrollment authorities.
Those changes are procedural, and they are the ones that will affect the most organizations. A provider that has never had to report an ownership change within 30 days, or a plan that has handled a suspected fraud internally, will have to build new processes.
Medicaid and CHIP
The Medicaid provisions reach into state administration. The rule would require electronic visit verification data in prepayment review and fraud investigations, require national provider identifier collection for all eligible providers, and require states to report denials and terminations monthly.
It would add new grounds for denying or terminating enrollment, including felonies and abusive billing, and expand ownership disclosures. It would replace the Medicaid Eligibility Quality Control program with federally overseen eligibility audits and related disallowances. It would create a 60-day rule for reporting and returning Medicaid fee-for-service overpayments, and it would enhance the payment error rate measurement and program-integrity corrective action plans.
States will carry much of the implementation burden. The rule's own cost estimate, about $379 million from 2027 to 2036, is small relative to the projected savings, and it does not capture the administrative work that states and providers will do to comply.
The provider burden
The rule's cost estimate is about $379 million from 2027 to 2036, which is small relative to the projected savings. The estimate covers the paperwork and systems the rule requires. It does not capture the full cost of new compliance staff, legal review, or the operational changes that a 30-day reporting deadline implies.
Those costs are real, and they fall disproportionately on small practices and safety-net providers. A large health system has compliance officers and legal teams. A small clinic may have a single administrator who also handles billing and credentialing. The rule's comment file will likely reflect that difference.
The agency's response is likely to be that the costs are justified by the savings and that the requirements are risk-based. The final rule may include exemptions or phased timelines for small providers. Those details will matter as much as the headline provisions.
The Marketplace
The Marketplace provisions focus on agents and brokers. The rule would give CMS authority to suspend agents and brokers immediately when there is a credible allegation of abusive conduct, add felony and exclusion restrictions, and limit system access from outside the United States.
The broker provisions respond to a specific problem: enrollment fraud in the Marketplace has involved agents changing or creating applications without the consumer's knowledge. A suspension authority gives CMS a faster tool than a lengthy investigation, and the system-access limits address a common route for unauthorized changes.
Where the number comes from
The $90 billion projection is a sum of estimated recoveries and avoided payments across the programs. It assumes the rule is finalized, implemented, and enforced as designed. It also assumes that the behavior changes the rule is meant to produce occur.
Those assumptions are reasonable for a regulatory impact analysis, and they are not a forecast of any individual provider's or plan's experience. A hospital, a physician group, or a Medicare Advantage plan should read the rule for the specific obligations it creates, not for the aggregate savings number.
The rule follows a February 2026 request for information that drew more than 560 comments, an executive order creating a White House task force on fraud, and a CY 2027 final rule. CMS has said it intends to issue a CRUSH-style rule annually, which means the compliance obligations will keep evolving.
The comment period
The comment period runs for 60 days after publication, with comments due January 19, 2027. Comments can be submitted through the Federal Register docket, and they become part of the public record.
The most effective comments tend to be specific. A provider that describes a concrete operational burden, with numbers, is more persuasive than a letter that objects to the rule in general. A plan that models the RADV change and shows the range of outcomes is more persuasive than one that asserts the method is unfair.
The final rule will follow the comment period. The agency can revise the provisions, change the effective dates, or drop pieces of the proposal. The direction, toward more verification, is likely to remain.
The debate
The case for the rule is straightforward. CMS spends more than a trillion dollars a year, and the agency's own estimates say a meaningful share is lost to fraud, waste, and abuse. The tools in the rule, from enrollment screening to audit extrapolation, are the ones the agency says it needs to protect the programs.
The case against is about burden and fairness. Providers argue that new reporting requirements and broader revocation authority can penalize errors or administrative failures that are not fraud. States argue that unfunded mandates strain their budgets. Plans argue that extrapolation can produce recoveries that exceed the actual harm.
The comment period is where those arguments will be made. The final rule may narrow some provisions and keep others. The direction, toward more verification and more reporting, is likely to survive.
What providers should watch
The first item is the enrollment reporting requirement. A 30-day deadline for ownership and enrollment changes requires a process, not just a policy. The second is the revocation authority. A provider with a complicated ownership structure should understand how the agency will assess verifiability.
The third is the audit exposure. A Medicare Advantage plan should model the RADV extrapolation under the new method and understand the range of outcomes. The fourth is the Medicaid overpayment rule, which creates a 60-day clock for reporting and returning identified overpayments.
The rule is proposed, and the details will change. The direction is clear enough that preparation can start now.
Primary sources
- CMS press release of November 16, 2026, for the rule's scope, the savings projection, and the agency's description of the CRUSH initiative.
- CMS fact sheet on the CRUSH proposed rule, CMS-6098-P, for the program-by-program provisions.
- Federal Register, 91 FR 74680, November 19, 2026, for the publication date, comment deadline, and regulatory text.